ABOVE: ALL LIQUORED UP WITH A MONASTIC CATHOLIC COCKTAIL
The author, Rod Dreher and his editor, Bria Sandford, raising a glass of Benedict Option to The Benedict Option
The author, Rod Dreher and his editor, Bria Sandford, raising a glass of Benedict Option to The Benedict Option
__________________________________________________________
BEER DRINKING PALS
Arthur W. Hunt III is professor of communications at The University of Tennessee at Martin and author of Surviving Technopolis: Essays on Finding Balance in Our New Manmade Environments (Pickwick, 2013). He also recently had a beer with Rod Dreher, seen here.
"THE BENEDICT OPTION":
THE FRUIT OF A COMPROMISED CHURCH
SEE OUR PREVIOUS POST:
republished below in full unedited for informational, educational, and research purposes:
…Has it come to this, that monkery
is to be revived in a professedly Protestant Church?…For the love you
bear to your Redeemer, be duped no longer, and by your own hatred of
monkery and priestcraft, come ye out from among them, be ye separate, and touch not the unclean thing
–Charles Spurgeon
Evangelical Christians have recently had an eye-opening experience. Even before the book The Benedict Option: A Strategy for Christians in a Post-Christian Nation had
hit the stands, it was already causing a stir. According to David
Brooks of the New York Times, it is “the most discussed and most
important religious book of the decade.”(source) A cover story in Christianity Today described it as a vision for a Christian village on “how to conserve and strengthen the American church.” (source)And then others quickly joined the cause, which included;
Albert Mohler, President of The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (source), Matt Chandler, President of the Acts 29 Network and pastor of The Village Church (source), Russell Moore, President of the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention (source), Carl R.Trueman, Westminster [PA] Theological Seminary, and John Piper, founder and teacher of desiringGod.org (source), and chancellor of Bethlehem College & Seminary.
For some, they were left scratching their heads trying to figure out why the ideas of a sixth-century monk, who spent three years in a dark cave, would be presented to evangelicals as an example to follow. (Particularly, when the author of the book, Rod Dreher, makes the statement “…the West owes an incalculable debt to Benedictine monks.”)
On the other hand, for those who have been warning the Church about the carelessness of evangelical leaders, this was just one more example exposing the Downgrade in our midst. Hence, the extent of the problem is now on full display as we witness high profile leaders throwing their support behind a book predicated on the false notion that for Christianity to survive a collapsing culture, evangelicals should band together and follow the example of Saint Benedict of Norcia, a man canonized a saint by the Roman Catholic church in the year 1220 and named patron protector of Europe by Pope Paul VI in 1964. What does this say about our current condition?
Remarkably, even before the book was available in bookstores, on February 13, 2017, Al Mohler devoted a whole radio program to the book. It was obvious from the interview Mohler followed Dreher’s work closely and even told his listeners, “…the book is very important and I want to commend it to every thinking Christian, we ought to read this book and we ought also to read far beyond the title.” (source)
During the interview, Dreher described his life as,
…shaped around liturgy that’s been in the church for 1500 years. My life is shaped around chanting the Psalms and on all kinds of sensual ways that embody the faith. But for me as an Orthodox Christian and me as a Catholic, the faith had more traction and it drew me in closer and closer. I don’t know if evangelicals can do that…In response, Mohler concurred with his guest, “I do not believe evangelicalism has sufficient resources to survive either this epoch or much beyond.” But, it was apparent Mohler felt his guest did understand the “resources” needed for evangelicals to survive a secular assault on our faith and our families.
To the contrary, it doesn’t require a PhD in theology to discern the “resources” found in the model and example of Saint Benedict will serve to increase numbers in the Catholic church, not strengthen evangelicals. And for sure, this is not the biblical response on how the Church will survive amid a collapsing culture? Instead, it will serve to undermine it.
Nevertheless, Rod Dreher told Mohler’s audience that it is
time for Christians to take seriously the times we’re in, to read the signs of the times and to respond in a responsible way… And I use Saint Benedict of Norcia, the sixth-century saint, …He went out to the woods to pray; he lived in a cave for three years and asked God to show him what to do with his life. He ended up coming out and founding a monastic order… They tendered within those monasteries the Scriptures, the prayers, the liturgies, and the old ways of doing things.With more airtime given to him, Dreher illustrated further his passion for the way of Saint Benedict. He said,
One of the stories I tell in the book is about going to the Benedictine monastery in Norcia, a small town in the mountains of central Italy, that was where they say Benedict was born…. Napoleon closed it down in 1810, but in the year 2000 some American monks went there and reopened it. And they wanted to sing the traditional Latin mass, and it’s become a real oasis of Christian peace and beauty. Well, it’s the sort of place where you go there up in the mountains, and you really envy these men, their peace, where they can worship and meet visitors.(See video clip of the monks of Norcia: source)
In other publications Rod Dreher has stated, the “1,500-year-old Benedictine way of life is a model for us.” He has also said, “Benedictine spirituality is a practical spirituality, a way of Christian living that consecrates the routines of the every day.” (source)
What is “Benedictine Spirituality”?
Per a 2014 article written in The American Conservative by Rod Dreher, titled, “Meditation & The Jesus Prayer,” Dreher described and acknowledged his prayer life had included praying the rosary as a Catholic, but now says he uses a “rosary-like prayer rope to pray the Jesus Prayer.” (The “Jesus Prayer” is also mentioned in The Benedict Option.) (source)
Dreher states the repetitious line of “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy upon me, a sinner” said repeatedly is indeed “contemplative and meditative.” He also defends it saying, “it is well grounded within ancient, unbroken Christian practice going back to the Desert Fathers of the early church.” (source)
In the same article, a link was provided to “a short primer,” to obtain more information on “the practice of the Jesus Prayer.” Oddly, he also cautions readers regarding the practice due to the similarities in breathing techniques used in “yoga or transcendental meditation and the like.” Therein lies one of the greatest dangers and deceptions of this practice. (source)
This primer also provided the following information; “The history of the Jesus Prayer goes back, as far as we know, to the early sixth century, with Diadochos, who taught that repetition of the prayer leads to inner stillness.” The primer also acknowledges the influence of John Cassian, who was celebrated for his mystical writings. It is said Cassian, in turn, influenced the teachings of Saint Benedict. (source)
Further information in the short primer includes instruction on how to breathe correctly while repeating the Jesus Prayer: “If we pray the Jesus Prayer for short periods, ten or fifteen minutes at the beginning, then there is no problem matching the words of the prayer to our breath. We are to breathe naturally, without playing with the rhythm of the breath. On the inhale, we can say, ‘Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God.’ On the exhale, we can say, ‘have mercy on me, a sinner.’ We are to breathe and pray slowly reverently and attentively.”
The book itself builds on the prayer life of Benedictine monks by pointing out their support of this Prayer. Per the author, Father Basil told him, “…as you have discovered with the Jesus Prayer…You have to set aside time for it.” The author also draws attention to other Benedictine spiritual practices, which includes several hours “daily of doing Lectio Divina.” (source)
It is telling that it is not only concerned Christians who have noticed that the trajectory of the book is to highlight the historical workings and roots of ancient Catholicism and the Orthodox religion. When even New York Times writer David Brookes, observes, “The heroes of Rod’s book are almost all monks,” our question should be “Why?” instead of just blindly following.
Our own review of the book confirms what others are saying: “Dreher presents a radical vision for the future of Christian life, and calls on American Christians to embrace an ancient way of life modeled by St. Benedict, a sixth-century monk who built enduring and separatist Christian communities focused on prayer, hospitality, and spiritual practice.” (source)
When Evangelicals begin opening doors to canonized saints, they also open other doors.
If The Benedict Option is given any more ground than it has already been given, we can expect more spiritual confusion to follow. Giving the Church a taste for Saint Benedict will inevitably introduce other aspects of Rome.
In the words of its author, the goal is the “rediscovering” of “an old tradition…we need to go back to the early church to see how our ancestors did it, see what they did, see how they embodied the faith and culture and practices.” (source)
It should be obvious, there are other disturbing issues besides the spiritual and theological persuasions of the author, Rod Dreher. Although Mohler acknowledges the difference that exists between their two faith perspectives, he also says evangelicals can learn from Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholicism without compromising their theological convictions.
But, once again, he is underestimating the power of error, and using poor judgment not consistent with Scripture. More importantly, did Jesus and the apostles encourage learning from the Pharisees?”
Furthermore, this growing willingness to excuse and accommodate biblically unsound teaching, or provide a platform for error and falsehood, is troubling. Moreover, to any believer in Christ, who left the Catholic church precisely because of its teachings, will be stunned to know certain evangelical leaders now think the teachings of a prominent monk are worthy of their attention.
Also, past writings of The Benedict Option author indicate a misunderstanding of the nature of Christ’s sacrifice. A stated personal belief on both purgatory and ghosts should give pause to those inclined to give him access to evangelicals.
Despite Scripture saying, “And inasmuch as it is appointed for men to die once and after this comes the judgment (Hebrews 9:27),” Dreher has stated;
…I believe…the soul survives the death of the body. As for ghosts, I believe that in some cases, God allows the spirits of the dead to visit the living, and in other cases those spirits are unhappily bound to the earth in a kind of purgatorial state, from which they need the help of the living to respond to divine grace and be free to move on… I have seen haunted houses, including my mom and dad’s place, freed of ghosts by Christian prayer, and that is the most important thing I need to know. My local friend, a Catholic, told me the ghost left her house after she told it to depart in the name of Jesus. (source), (more on purgatory)Hence, such being the case, regardless of the author’s good intentions, Christians should not spend their hard-earned money on this book.
Scripture warns “Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness.” ( Ephesians 5:11) Yet, we find this great evangelical disaster picking up steam in our midst. Regardless of anything helpful found in the book, why would evangelical men give any support to an idea highlighting a false religious system as an answer to survive a corrupt culture and a worldly church?
Also, instead of adhering to the words found in Scripture regarding our response to error, and our fellowship with those who espouse error, it is becoming increasingly apparent men are finding their own ways of doing things. Consequently, they ignore the warning:
Watch yourselves…If anyone comes to
you and does not bring this teaching, do not receive him into your
house, and do not give him a greeting, for the one who gives him a
greeting participates in his evil deeds. —2 John 8-11
To those who left Roman Catholicism behind to embrace the sufficiency
of Scripture and salvation found in Christ alone, to those who threw
away their rosaries with all its Hail Mary’s, to those who abandoned the
teachings of a church that embraces purgatory and praying to canonized
saints, to those who left Rome, there will be no turning back. They will
want no part of Saint Benedict’s strategy for Christians.Lastly, it is incumbent on us to heed warnings from men who have proven they understand the battles of our day. A.W. Pink is one of those men:
“To turn away from the lifeless preachers and Publishers of the day—may involve a real cross. Your motives will be misconstrued, your words perverted, and your actions misinterpreted. The sharp arrows of false report will be directed against you. You will be called proud and self-righteous because you refuse to fellowship empty professors. You will be termed censorious and bitter—if you condemn in plain speech—the subtle delusions of Satan. You will be dubbed narrow-minded and uncharitable because you refuse to join in singing the praises of the “great” and “popular” men of the day. More and more, you will be made to painfully realize—that the path which leads unto eternal life is “narrow” and that FEW there are who find it. May the Lord be pleased to grant unto each of us—the hearing ear and obedient heart! “Take heed what you hear” and read!” (source)
For am I now seeking the approval of
man, or of God? Or am I trying to please man? If I were still trying to
please man, I would not be a servant of Christ. —Galatians 1:10
(Note: Link to the above Charles Spurgeon quote: (http://www.spurgeon.org/tract09.php )[Source: Gumprecht/Mickels]
** Pulpit & Pen will be posting a book review on Dreher’s “The Benedict Option” soon.
_______________________________________________________
Attacks on the Gospel's Exclusivity
by MIKE GENDRON
Tragically, his strategy has been successful and is gaining a great deal of traction. Most recently, Al Mohler, Carl Truman, Russell Moore and Matt Chandler
have recommended a disturbingly popular book written by Rod Dreher, who
is a major promoter of Roman Catholicism, ecumenical unity, and
contemplative prayer. Dreher is a former Catholic who converted to the
Eastern Orthodox religion, not because of Rome's false gospel, but
because of its sexual abuse scandal. His book, The Benedict Option,
calls people of faith to emulate a sixth-century Catholic monk as an
example of how to live in a collapsing culture. Almost all the heroes of
The Benedict Option are Catholic monks who lived solitary lives in a monastery while participating in the daily sacrifice of a Eucharistic Christ.
Like most proponents of
ecumenism, Dreher promotes subjective spiritual experiences over the
objective truths of Scripture. He said he never had a problem with
praying the rosary as a Catholic, and he now encourages his readers to
practice contemplative prayer and mysticism. He said "my life is shaped
around liturgy that's been in our church for 1500 years" and "on all
kinds of sensual ways that embody the faith." His Eastern Orthodox
religion preaches the same works-righteousness salvation as Catholicism
and other religions. We are not to affirm or receive "anyone who goes
too far and does not abide in the teaching of Christ" (2 John 9-10).
For
evangelical leaders to recommend a book that applauds the heretical
people and traditions of Roman Catholicism during the 500th anniversary
of the Reformation is lamentable. The prevailing influence of these
leaders, along with their reluctance to guard sound doctrine and reject
false gospels, have left many Christians confused. They do not know if
the Roman Catholic Church represents a huge mission field that needs to
be evangelized or if it represents a valid expression of Christianity.
They need to know that Catholicism has long been a bitter enemy of the Gospel of Christ. The apostate religion has not only condemned those who believe the Gospel, but brutally tortured and killed
hundreds of thousands of those who refused to compromise it.
Evangelical leaders who are sanctioning ecumenical unity with Catholics
must be lovingly confronted in their error with the truth of God's
Word.
this book, and we ought also to read far beyond the title." Yet, there was a glaring omission both in the book and in the interview by Mohler and Dreher. Neither one referenced the most powerful tools Jesus Christ gave us to fight the cultural wars - His Word and His Gospel (Hebrews 4:12; Romans 1:16).
Evangelicals who endorse a book that obfuscates the lines that once separated biblical Christianity from apostate Christianity are
minimizing the powerful effect of error. The accommodation of doctrinal
error and falsehood will always be dangerous to the life of the Church
that is called to be sanctified by the truth (John 17:17).
God's Word warns us to "be on your guard so that you are not carried
away by the error of unprincipled men and fall from your own
steadfastness" (2 Pet. 3:17). The
critical issue in the church today is the purity of the Gospel. It is
the rudder that must guide us through stormy waters that have been
stirred up by every wind of doctrine (Eph. 4:14). Either we seek the approval of God by protecting the purity of the Gospel or we seek the approval of men by applauding those who peddle another gospel. There is no "option."
As blood-bought Christians, we must contend earnestly for the faith and challenge those
who embrace a false gospel. If we fail to fight the good fight of
faith, we leave our own convictions and beliefs open to question. There
is so much more at stake than winning cultural wars. We are also
fighting the age-old war against truth waged by the powers of darkness.
The truth of God's Word is our only hope in in a world spinning out of
control. We must endeavor to defend the glory and honor of our Lord
Jesus Christ, the purity of His Gospel, and the sanctity of His Church.
_________________________________________________________
An Introduction to St Benedict of Nursia's The Rule of Saint Benedict- A Macat Theology Analysis
"CHRISTIAN" OR CATHOLIC???
THEY CAN'T BE THE SAME GOSPEL, EXCEPT IF YOUR "CHRISTIANITY" IS SALVATION BY WORKS,
NOT GRACE
THE INFLUENCE OF DREHER'S "BENEDICT OPTION"
THEY CAN'T BE THE SAME GOSPEL, EXCEPT IF YOUR "CHRISTIANITY" IS SALVATION BY WORKS,
NOT GRACE
THE INFLUENCE OF DREHER'S "BENEDICT OPTION"
ON THE ANABAPTIST "BRUDERHOF", FORMERLY OF THE HUTTERITE CHURCH
THE BRUDERHOF ATTEND DREHER'S EVENT
IN NEW YORK CITY
Published on Mar 18, 2017
For
most of last week I was pretty busy helping out at two events
surrounding the release of Rod Dreher's new book on the Benedict Option,
so here's a few highlights of Thursday in New York City and Friday at
Fox Hill. —Melinda
Rod Dreher: The Benedict Option
A strategy for Christians in a post-Christian world
CATHOLIC CARDINAL DOLAN VISITS THE BRUDERHOF IN RIFTON, NEW YORK
FOLK SINGER, SOCIAL ACTIVIST & COMMUNIST,
PETE SEEGER VISITS THE BRUDERHOF
Published on Aug 17, 2012
On
August 15, 2012 Cardinal Timothy Dolan made a visit to the Woodcrest
Bruderhof in Rifton NY. In the spirit of solidarity and Christian
fellowship, the discussion touched on how to keep an open dialogue with
and heart to all humankind. Conversations included the importance of
nurturing children and young people and how the deep joy of a
faith-filled life is an invitation to others to discover Jesus. The late
Pope John Paul II spoke along these lines as well: "Even in struggle
solidarity remains open to dialogue," and "Solidarity, of its very
nature, provokes action (including, at times, confrontation) but it does
so always on the basis of a vision of community and of calling to full
membership of that community."
FOLK SINGER, SOCIAL ACTIVIST & COMMUNIST,
PETE SEEGER VISITS THE BRUDERHOF
